Century21 Logo



+1 (902) 436-2265

Why is my PEI home not selling as quickly as I expected

Selling a home in the PEI real estate market can sometimes take longer than expected, even with the guidance of a knowledgeable REALTOR® and even in our recent market. To ensure a smooth and successful sale, it’s essential to understand the various factors that can impact the process. Here are some common reasons why PEI homes may not sell as quickly as anticipated, along with helpful tips to address these issues:

Pricing is often a critical factor in determining whether or not a home sells quickly in the PEI real estate market. Setting the right price for your property is essential to attracting potential buyers and generating interest. If a home is overpriced, it may deter prospective buyers who perceive the property as being beyond their budget or not offering good value for the asking price. Conversely, underpricing your home might lead to a quick sale, but at the expense of potential profits. It’s crucial to work with an experienced PEI REALTOR® who can conduct a comprehensive market analysis, taking into account factors such as recent sales of comparable homes, current market conditions, and your home’s unique features. By setting a competitive and realistic price that reflects the true value of your property, you will be more likely to attract the right buyers and achieve a successful sale.

In Prince Edward Island, the real estate market demonstrates a distinct pattern when it comes to the time it takes for properties to sell, depending on their price range. Homes priced at $300,000 or less generally sell very quickly, often within a matter of days, as they cater to a larger pool of buyers seeking affordable options. Properties in the $300,000 to $500,000 range tend to stay on the PEI real estate market for a longer period, as they appeal to a somewhat smaller demographic with more specific preferences. For homes in the higher price brackets, attracting an appropriate buyer can be more challenging and require considerably greater marketing efforts. These luxury properties cater to an exclusive clientele with discerning tastes, and it may take extra time and resources to find the right match. To ensure success in selling a PEI property in any of these price ranges, it’s crucial to work closely with an experienced island REALTOR® who understands the nuances of the local real estate market and can tailor the marketing strategy accordingly.

While the price of your home plays a significant role in attracting potential buyers and determining the speed at which your property sells when listed on the PEI MLS system, it is essential to understand that there are other factors involved in the home marketing process. The price tag alone does not guarantee a quick sale. Recognizing that the selling process is multifaceted and complex will help you approach the sale with a comprehensive strategy, addressing all aspects that contribute to a successful outcome.

The appeal of your home’s location on Prince Edward Island can greatly influence buyer interest. Address any potential location-related issues and capitalize on the unique features of your property’s surroundings to make your home more attractive to prospective buyers. Your REALTOR® can offer valuable insights and suggestions for improvements that could enhance your home’s location appeal.

Ensuring your PEI property is well-maintained and updated before listing it for sale can make it more appealing to a broader range of buyers. Address any maintenance concerns and consider updating outdated elements to demonstrate that the home has been well cared for, increase buyer confidence, and ultimately speed up the selling process.

If your home is unconventional homes with unique features – patience is key. These features may appeal to a smaller subset of buyers. Work closely with your REALTOR® to showcase your home’s distinct qualities and determine the most appropriate asking price. This will help you find the right buyer who truly appreciates your PEI property’s uniqueness.

Finally, address any lingering odours in your home, as they can significantly influence buyer perception. Invest in a professional deep clean and consider using air fresheners, opening windows, or incorporating pleasant scents to create an inviting atmosphere. By addressing these potential obstacles, you can present a clean, well-maintained, and appealing home, increasing your chances of a successful sale.

By maintaining open communication with your professional PEI real estate salesperson and addressing these common issues, you can work together to develop an effective marketing strategy that maximizes your property’s appeal and ultimately leads to finding the right buyer. With a bright, positive, and helpful approach, you’ll be well-equipped to navigate the challenges of the home-selling process and achieve the best possible outcome.

Ron Barrett - Century21 Northumberland - PEI Realtor


I am Ron Barrett, co-owner and broker at Century21 Northumberland Realty. I and my team of 30+ professional real estate agents would be pleased to help you with all your Prince Edward Island real estate needs. I can be reached at 902.888.7238 or ron@century21pei.com

In today’s economic landscape, characterized by high market prices and elevated interest rates, the prevailing belief might be that the younger generations in Canada, particularly those categorized as Gen Z or Millennials, are shying away from the prospect of homeownership. However, this narrative doesn’t entirely align with the reality, especially when looking at the PEI real estate market. Despite these financial barriers, a significant number of young Canadians remain eager to embark on the journey of buying a home, with many setting their sights on the picturesque landscapes and vibrant communities of Prince Edward Island (PEI).

Spanning across two distinct age groups, Millennials and Gen Z represent a broad demographic spectrum. Millennials, now aged in their late 20s to early 40s, and Gen Z, the generation born between 1997 and 2012, together, comprise a formidable segment of the Canadian population. With over 6.7 million Canadians classified as Gen Z, their economic impact and potential as future homeowners is undeniable. This is particularly true in the PEI real estate market, where the unique charm and appeal of the island are drawing in younger buyers from across Canada looking for both value and quality of life.

Despite the challenges posed by the current economic climate, including a higher cost of living and inflation rates, the desire for homeownership remains strong. Insights from REALTOR.ca for the last quarter of 2023 indicated that a majority of its users, specifically 55.4%, were aged between 18 and 44 years, many of whom are actively exploring PEI real estate opportunities. This interest is further underscored by findings from a 2022 Royal Lepage Demographic survey, which revealed that 60% of Millennials not yet homeowners believe they will be in the future, with 51% aiming to purchase within the next five years. Moreover, a report from the Bank of Montreal suggests that 68% of Canadians are biding their time, waiting for interest rates to decline before entering the market, a strategy that could be particularly wise.

The optimism and determination to own a home vary across regions, with attitudes towards the feasibility of this goal differing from one area to another. However, the PEI real estate market offers a beacon of hope for many, with relatively more accessiblibility compared to urban centers in other provinces. This has made PEI a particularly attractive option for Millennials and Gen Z buyers looking for both affordability and a high quality of life.

The paths to homeownership are as diverse as the individuals pursuing them, with many young buyers adopting innovative strategies to navigate the real estate market. It’s clear that there’s a growing interest in condominiums among first-time homebuyers, driven by a more deliberate approach in a market that has become more buyer-friendly post-pandemic. PEI realtors also highlight the financial savvy of younger buyers, many of whom opt for minimal down payments and leverage first-time homebuyer incentives to make their dreams a reality.

Renting, too, has emerged as a strategic step toward eventual homeownership, with many in the Gen Z cohort seeing it as a necessary stage in their journey. This trend is particularly notable in PEI, where although the real estate rental market is tight with low vacancy rates renting can still serve as a stepping stone for young individuals aiming to save for their future homes. PEI realtors observe that an increasing number of their clients are opting for rental arrangements, often with roommates or siblings, as a way to manage living costs while planning for homeownership.

Furthermore, the shift towards remote work has expanded the geographic considerations of potential homebuyers, making PEI real estate even more appealing. The island’s beauty, coupled with its more affordable market, has attracted buyers from far and wide, with some willing to move from bustling city centers to embrace the peace and community spirit of PEI.

The aspiration to establish a solid financial foundation and secure a place in the real estate market remains a common thread among younger Canadians. PEI realtors and the PEI real estate market play a pivotal role in turning these aspirations into reality, offering guidance, insights, and opportunities tailored to the needs and dreams of younger buyers. Despite the financial challenges of today, the commitment to homeownership is unwavering, with many young individuals viewing the current market conditions as a temporary hurdle rather than an insurmountable barrier.

For those considering the leap into homeownership, consulting with a Century21 realtor can provide invaluable insights into the current market trends, personalized advice, and a clear understanding of financial readiness. The expertise of Century21 realtors in navigating the local market can empower prospective buyers to make informed decisions, ensuring that their journey towards owning a home on Prince Edward Island is both strategic and successful.

Scroll to Top